Restaurants

Water Street Bistro

4.4 62 reviews Closed 10 Main St #201, New Paltz, NY 12561, United States

Discover this place

Water Street Bistro, nestled at 10 Main St in New Paltz, NY, delivers a delightful culinary experience that captures the essence of casual dining. This charming bistro is known for its diverse menu, featuring favorites like the Hot Honey Chicken Pizza and the savory BBQ Chicken Pizza, both priced at an accessible $18.41. Customers rave about the rich flavors and generous portions. Chef/owner engagement adds a personal touch, with heartfelt service frequently highlighted in reviews.

Scott Anderson praised the delectable food, emphasizing the worth of the wait, while Austin Garner appreciated the friendly and attentive service. The unique offerings, including the creamy Cheesecake ($5.99), provide a sweet finish to the meal. Outdoor seating enhances the experience, creating a cozy atmosphere for diners as they enjoy a bite before exploring nearby Water Street Market.

Despite its compact size, Water Street Bistro stands tall in its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. As Stephanie Posada noted, the fried chicken is far from frozen; it’s a genuine delight. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this bistro is a must-visit for food lovers.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Tourists
University students

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Water Street Bistro before visiting.

Reviews for Water Street Bistro

4.4

62 reviews

Review highlights

Based on 62 reviews

Water Street Bistro in New Paltz is frequently praised for its flavorful, well-portioned dishes offered at reasonable prices. Reviewers consistently highlight the friendly and genuine customer service, often noting the chef's personal engagement with guests. While the restaurant's indoor space is small with limited seating, many appreciate the nearby courtyard seating which adds a relaxed atmosphere. Menu favorites include standout fried chicken and creative sandwiches, though some find certain items average or slightly overpriced. Overall, Water Street Bistro is recognized for its welcoming vibe, fresh ingredients, and a commitment to delivering a pleasant dining experience, making it a recommended stop for both locals and visitors.

Scott Anderson

Oct 22, 2025

Absolutely great food, portions and prices are on point went on mother's day they said 25 mins got there food wasn't done he asked for 5 more sure no problem I would have gave him another 15 min cuz the food was absolutely amazing. I will definitely be back.

Austin Garner

Sep 17, 2025

Great food from a friendly chef. Wasn't just customer service voice, I could tell he wanted me to have good food and service. Definitely going back when I can

Mark Little

Aug 21, 2025

My wife got the honey chicken sammich, loved it. We were visiting from out of state. The chef/owner was so friendly and engaging with her while preparing the meal that he gave it to her without ringing it up (it was the very end of the day). We paid over the phone a few days later, he was very gracious.

Amber Relyea

Aug 18, 2025

The counter person was very accommodating and friendly. There is no seating inside. Very small space. But there is seating in the courtyard steps away. My boyfriend ordered the Trailblazer burger. He said it was average and overpriced. I ordered the chicken gyro, it was good, and the portion was large. It was interesting to have French fries and pickles in it. I think the gyro was priced fairly. It was very convenient as we were visiting Water Street Market and there aren't many places to have a casual bite.

Stephanie Posada

Aug 17, 2025

Best fried chicken I’ve had in a long time. Not those pre frozen chicken either. Real deal. Loved it with a cute place to sit outside, eat, relax, and play chess.

Shari Raymond

Aug 08, 2025

WOW! Great food. Had the spicy chicken sandwich and Bistro burger. You will not leave hungry! What a delight to find in New Paltz, NY

Deborah Sarmir

Jul 22, 2025

Great little place to stop for pub food and cocktails! The nachos were terrific, and the cocktails were strong! We will definitely be going back for another visit!

Zack Tashoff

Jul 14, 2025

I’m very picky about my burgers and the Bistro Burger was SO delicious that I had to go back the next day for another one! There’s no seating inside so plan to either eat outside or bring back home. Water street is a great place to eat outside when it’s warm, and has some cool shops to check out after a great meal from Main Street Bistro!